Logo
  Saturday, July 11, 2020
Sign-In  |  Sign-Up  |  Contact Us  |  Bookmark 

The upper house of Russia's parliament passed a federal law Friday to reinstate disciplinary isolation cells in the country's armed forces
The upper house of Russia's parliament passed a federal law Friday to reinstate disciplinary isolation cells, or guardhouses, in the country's armed forces. The regulations, approved by the lower house, the State Duma, November 15, call for the detention of servicemen for disciplinary violations and temporary confinement in guardhouses for up to 30 days, and in certain cases up to 45 days. Guardhouses in the armed forces were banned in the summer of 2002, as decisions to confine servicemen were usually made by commanding officers, in breach of the Constitution. According to the regulations set out in the bill, decisions to detain servicemen must be made in line with military regulations, by a military garrison court judge. A serviceman has the right to a lawyer and to appeal the court's decision. The law also states that only junior male servicemen can be confined in guardhouses, while officers and female servicemen cannot. The law is expected to come into force January 1, 2007 if it receives the approval of the president. But the decision to reinstate guardhouses was met with criticism from some of Russia's human rights activists, who said they feared the new law will help cover up hazing attacks in the military, and might result in arbitrariness among officers. Valentina Melnikova, chairwoman of the Union of Soldiers Mothers' Committees of Russia, said the idea of the law on guardhouses will only help prosecutors, courts martial and the Defense Ministry to formally though not actually reduce crime statistics in the armed forces, by classifying crimes, including hazing, as disciplinary violations. The Russian military has been plagued by a series of hazing incidents in recent years that have led to the death or injury of low-ranking soldiers. The most notorious case involved a New Year assault on Private Andrei Sychyov by older servicemen, which led to the amputation of his legs and genitals and provoked an outcry throughout Russia. "Beating, which is classified in the Criminal Code as non-regulation relations, could be classified not as a crime, but as a disciplinary violation," Melnikova said. She also voiced concern over the selectiveness of the new law, as it will mainly be applied to soldiers. "It can be applied to soldiers, but not to officers and warrant officers. That is discrimination," she said. Anatoly Kucherena, a lawyer and the head of the Russian Public Chamber's commission on public control over law enforcement agencies and reforms in the legal and judicial system, said the re-introduction of guardhouses could sideline humanitarian principles and lead to arbitrariness among officers. "There is a concern that this institution [of guardhouses], which has now been re-introduced, could be abused by some officers," said Kucherena, who was actively involved in the resolution of Sychyov hazing case. Addressing the new provision on confinement decision-making by military garrison courts, Kucherena said it was a positive decision, adding he hoped that judges will thoroughly consider possible disciplinary violations. But Lyudmila Alekseyeva, a veteran of the Russian human rights movement and head of the Moscow Helsinki Group, was not optimistic about either guardhouses or decisions being made by military garrison courts, saying it will only create opportunities for human rights violations. "Guardhouses are located on the territories of military units," Alekseyeva said, pointing out that judges will not be checking guardhouse regimes and how those confined there are treated. "This puts a detainee into a dependent position on those who decided his punishment." She said she believed that even if a decision to send a serviceman to a guardhouse is made by a military garrison court, the terms of the punishment itself will in reality be determined by a commanding officer.
Print The upper house of Russia's parliament passed a federal law Friday to reinstate disciplinary isolation cells in the country's armed forces Bookmark The upper house of Russia's parliament passed a federal law Friday to reinstate disciplinary isolation cells in the country's armed forces

Related News   
OctNovember 2006Dec
MoTuWeThFrSaSu
303112345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930123
45678910